Very, it turns out. There was no consistent way to tell whether small
manufacturers on the other side of the planet were any good. You could
buy shipping records from the U.S. Department of Homeland Security on
CD-ROM for $100 per day, but they were often incomplete, convoluted and
unorganized. Company names were misspelled. Addresses were incorrect.
"It
was like a jigsaw puzzle with 20 million pieces," says Green.
Then
Green met Jim Psota, an MIT graduate and computer whiz. Green told him
how hard it was to find reliable suppliers. There had to be a better way
of doing business, they agreed.
The idea: In 2006, Psota
and Green teamed up to start Panjiva,
a company with offices in Cambridge and New York City whose Web site
would scour millions of shipping records from databases all over the
Internet, allowing businesses to find and vet suppliers. The next year,
the company raised $400,000 in seed capital. In 2008, they closed a $5.2
million round of funding led by Battery Ventures.
The risk:
Panjiva faces stiff competition from established global intelligence
businesses like Dunn & Bradstreet, which focuses mostly on domestic
business' financial data, and Alibaba.com, which has a $1 billion
investment from Yahoo (YHOO,
Fortune
500) and showcases marketing information provided by overseas
suppliers.
But in the beginning, Panjiva's biggest challenge
wasn't facing down other companies. It was building something customers
actually wanted. In 2008, after months of software development, Green
and Psota were pleased with the search engine they'd built to help
businesses find suppliers. But when Green put it in the hands of
potential customers for a test run, the feedback was not what he
expected.
"They weren't impressed," says Green, 31. He and Psota
were incredulous; they thought their software was great. "Our first
impression was that our clients must not get it."
An investor
suggested the co-founders try it for themselves: run a real query
through their own software. When Green used the search engine to find a
sweater maker in Vietnam for a potential customer, it took much longer
than it should have.
"We saw firsthand it didn't work," Green
said. "The least relevant search results came up top."
Psota and
Green started again, building a better search engine that would bring up
more relevant answers.
Green says his biggest mistake was not
soliciting feedback earlier in the process. If he had, it could have
shaved off months of development time.
"It's a common mistake for
entrepreneurs," says Eric Sink, a software developer and the author of The
Business of Software. "I've seen more than one business go under
because a feedback loop wasn't there."
The reward: Three
years after its start, Panjiva's Web site works. It can search records
from 1.5 million companies in 190 countries. The technology also
identifies trends, predicting whether a specific supplier might soon go
belly up or projecting which products will be hot in the next holiday
season. Green declined to disclose revenues at the 10-employee firm, but
he says they've grown six-fold from 2008. Hundreds of clients --
including Guess Jeans, Home Depot and VF, the largest jeans maker in the
world -- now pay fees ranging from $99 to hundreds of thousands of
dollars for those reports.
Bob Petkun says Panjiva helped his
online craft supply company, Crafts Americana Group, grow by 30% and cut its travel
budget by $25,000. Before he stumbled upon Panjiva in a Google search
last year, Petkun would go to a craft store, find the type of product he
wanted to import -- say, a skein of yarn -- then look at its country of
origin and sometimes travel abroad to find a supplier.
"I would
never know where to look for vendors," says Petkun. "It's a big world." 